Pre-registration
Writing down the analysis plan before seeing the data.
Also known as: pre-registration, preregistration, analysis plan
Pre-registration means writing down the hypothesis, primary metric, analysis method and decision rule before the data arrives — and timestamping it where others can see. It separates decisions made with knowledge from decisions retrofitted to results, which is the only thing standing between analysis and story-telling with extra steps.
before launch: metric X, method Y, rule "ship if +2% significant" — written, dated
after launch: run exactly that. Deviations get their own dated note.
The mechanism is commitment, not bureaucracy. A short dated paragraph beats a ten-page template nobody reads; what matters is that the plan predates the result, so a “significant” finding cannot quietly become the hypothesis it was never designed to test.
The classic mistakes:
- Pre-registering everything equally. Exploratory work needs freedom to follow the data; confirmatory tests need chains. Pre-register the tests that will move decisions, and label the rest exploratory.
- Vague plans that permit anything. “We will analyse engagement” pre-registers nothing — any metric that moves can be crowned afterwards. Name the metric, the method and the rule precisely enough that someone else could run it.
- Treating the plan as unchangeable. Legitimate reasons to deviate appear (a bug, a broken variant). Deviate openly: note what changed, why, and what the original plan said — the audit trail is the point.
- No decision rule. A plan without a rule (“ship if…”) is a prediction, not a commitment. End every pre-registration with the action each outcome triggers.
- Confusing it with peeking prevention only. Pre-registration also stops metric-shopping, subgroup-hunting and hypothesis-swapping — the whole family of result-contingent choices.
The habit: no confirmatory analysis without a dated plan. It costs minutes, and it is the cheapest credibility an analyst can buy — see experiment design for what the plan should contain.